Call us: 415.613.4373
slide1 slide2 slide3 slide4 ‹ ›
image
text
text
image

Chocolate Toffee Crunch, Pumpkin Spice & Tuxedo Butter Cup!


Order Now

Try out our 3 November flavors-of-the-month, plus our *NEW* Mashup, Pumpkin Biscoff!

LEARN MORE
  • Our November Sampler features 3 special flavors-of-the-month: Chocolate Toffee Crunch, Pumpkin Spice and Tuxedo Butter Cup, plus 3 of our most popular classics: Butter Cup, Grandma's Chocolate Tea Cake and Red Velvet. While not included in the Sampler, our *NEW* Mashup, Pumpkin Biscoff (pumpkin spice cake with creamy Biscoff frosting), is also available all month long. So don't delay! Swing by our bakery or place your order today!
    • text
    image

    Giving Thanks


    Order Now

    For a fun twist on the traditional Thanksgiving pie, serve cupcakes (masquerading as pumpkin pie) at your Thanksgiving gathering!

    LEARN MORE
  • We've also got turkeys, cornucopias and other festive, hand-piped complimentary decorations for the holiday. Please note that we will be open on Wednesday, November 27 (the day before Thanksgiving), then closed from November 28-December 2. We are so thankful for our wonderful customers who have supported us for the past 20+ years. We hope to continue to make your celebrations sweeter for many years to come.
    • text
    image

    Thank You for Your Votes!


    Order Now

    We are so honored to be named the Best Party Food/Caterer on the Peninsula for the 10th year in a row by the readers of Bay Area Parent Magazine!

    LEARN MORE
  • Thanks to everyone who voted for us! We are so incredibly grateful for your continued and loyal support!
    • text

    How to Order


    LEARN MORE
  • Order Online
    • or
  • Call Us at 415-613-4373
    • or
  • Email Us cupcakes@sibbyscupcakery.com
    • text

    3 Different Sizes!


    LEARN MORE
  • Mini (2”) $43.20 dozen
  • Regular (3”) $59.40 dozen
  • Jumbo (4”) $14.85 each
    • text

    Lead Time


    LEARN MORE
  • We have cupcakes with our signature decorations available for same-day purchase. We do sell out occasionally.

  • For personalized orders, and specific flavors, sizes and quantities, please place your order in advance.

  • One to two days is typically enough notice. Custom orders often require more lead time.

  • Some Fridays, weekends and holidays book up a week in advance.
    • text

    Pickup


    LEARN MORE
  • We are located in downtown San Mateo.

  • We have individual cupcakes and Sibby's Sampler boxes for sale daily. Swing by or give us a call to check availability.

  • Pick-ups for orders placed in advance are by appointment.
    • text

    Delivery


    LEARN MORE
  • We deliver Wednesday through Saturday to most destinations from San Francisco to Sunnyvale.

  • Deliveries may arrive up to 2 hours before scheduled time. (Not to worry, the cupcakes are best stored and enjoyed at room temperature).