We provide one complimentary tasting per wedding (you may choose up to 4 flavors to try). We hold our tastings on the first Tuesday evening of every month from January through November. Because we bake our tasting cupcakes especially for each couple, we ask for 24 hours advance notice if you need to cancel for any reason. Our tastings are held at our bakery in downtown San Mateo. Please call us if you’d like to schedule a tasting. If you aren’t able to make it to a tasting, you may purchase a dozen mini size Sibby’s Sampler for pick up instead.  We are open Tuesday through Sunday and orders do need to be placed in advance.


Our delivery fee varies and is based on distance from the bakery. As an alternative, you are welcome to pick up the cupcakes from our bakery in downtown San Mateo (we have custom inserts that hold each cupcake in place). We also have a selection of tiered cake stands that are available for rent or purchase with an order. We can create a beautiful display for your cupcakes for $100 plus the cost of the stand rental.
Please see our wedding gallery at https://sibbyscupcakery.com for photos.


The prices on our website apply for weddings ($48/dozen for regular size, $33/dozen for mini size). Minis are about half the size of a regular size cupcake. We also sell Jumbo cupcakes individually ($12/each). They are about 4 1/2″ in diameter. Some couples like to use the Jumbo cupcake for the “cake” cutting ceremony.

There is no additional cost for customizing colors. An additional design fee may apply for particularly intricate decorations and monograms or custom fondant decorations.