◀︎   GO BACK
Call us: 415.613.4373
We are a nut-free bakery.
ORDER
SIGNATURE DESIGNS CLASSIC THEMES CUSTOM THEMES
WEDDINGS
ABOUT
CONTACT
CHECKOUT
ORDER
We are a nut-free bakery.
SIGNATURE DESIGNS CLASSIC THEMES CUSTOM THEMES
WEDDINGS
ABOUT
CONTACT

Select Cupcake Flavors (Traditional and/or Gluten-Free)

Browse through our selection of traditional and gluten-free flavors and click a photo for more information or to order online. After selecting your flavors, you'll have a chance to choose a color scheme and decoration theme from our Signature or Classic designs or place a custom order.

We are a peanut-free and tree nut-free bakery.

3 Different Sizes!

Sizes are approximate and vary based on flavor and handmade nature of our product.

photo
Jimmie Cake
Pumpkin Spice
Butter Cup
Chocolate & Cream
Grandma's Chocolate Tea Cake
Red Velvet

Sibby's Sampler - October

ADD TO BOX
photo
Vanilla cake with chocolate jimmies (cylindrical sprinkles) baked inside and topped with a swirl of our chocolate fudgy frosting and vanilla buttercream

Jimmie Cake - October Only

ADD TO BOX
photo
Moist Pumpkin Spice cupcake topped with ginger cream cheese frosting

Pumpkin Spice - Oct. & Nov. Only

ADD TO BOX
photo
5 layers of housemade chocolatey goodness:
1. Rich dark chocolate cake
2. Chocolate Swiss buttercream filling
3. Chocolate fudgy frosting
4. Chocolate ganache
5. Housemade chocolate cookie crumbs
If you are a chocolate lover, this one's for you!

Midnight Magic - October Only

ADD TO BOX
photo
Our decorating kits include:
• 1 dozen unfrosted cupcakes - (choose 2 cupcake flavors)
• 2 piping bags of frosting (choose 2 frosting flavors)
• Colorful sprinkles (choose 2 types – confetti, pastel nonpareils, rainbow nonpareils chocolate jimmies)
• Assorted fondant decorations
Note: Please let us know your preferences in the Special Instructions section of the order form.

Cupcake Decorating Kit

ADD TO BOX
photo
Vanilla cupcake with vanilla buttercream frosting

Butter Cup

ADD TO BOX
photo
Super-moist carrot cupcake with cinnamon cream cheese frosting

Carrot Cinnamon

ADD TO BOX
photo
Rich chocolate cupcake with Sibby's rich and fudgy chocolate frosting

Choco Choco

ADD TO BOX
photo
Rich chocolate cupcake with vanilla cream cheese frosting

Chocolate & Cream

ADD TO BOX
photo
Rich chocolate cupcake topped with vanilla cream cheese frosting and shredded coconut

Chocolate Coconut Cream

ADD TO BOX
photo
Coconut cupcake topped with vanilla cream cheese frosting and shredded coconut

Coconut Snowball

ADD TO BOX
photo
Confetti sprinkle cupcake topped with vanilla cream cheese frosting

Confetti Surprise

ADD TO BOX
photo
Vanilla cupcake with gooey caramel filling, topped with dulce de leche frosting

Dulce de Leche

ADD TO BOX
photo
Rich chocolate cupcake with cream cheese/chocolate chip center, topped with Sibby's rich and fudgy chocolate frosting

Grandma's Chocolate Tea Cake

ADD TO BOX
photo
Vanilla cupcake with espresso-infused coffee buttercream frosting

Latte Love

ADD TO BOX
photo
Light lemon cupcake with fresh lemon buttercream frosting

Lemon Drop

ADD TO BOX
photo
Rich chocolate cupcake with espresso-infused coffee buttercream frosting

Mmm Good Mocha

ADD TO BOX
photo
Vanilla cupcake with Sibby's rich and fudgy chocolate frosting

Old-Fashioned Birthday Cake

ADD TO BOX
photo
Classic red velvet cupcake with extra rich cream cheese frosting

Red Velvet

ADD TO BOX
photo
Brown sugar cupcake with homemade salted caramel filling and caramel cream cheese frosting

Salted Caramel

ADD TO BOX
photo
Snickerdoodle cupcake and cinnamon cream cheese frosting topped with sugar and spice and everything nice

Snickerdoodle

ADD TO BOX
photo
Extra rich "brownie-like" chocolate cupcake with glossy dark chocolate frosting

Super-Chewy Chocolate
(minis only)

ADD TO BOX
photo
Vanilla cupcake with vanilla buttercream frosting
Our gluten-free cupcakes are made with gluten-free ingredients

Gluten-Free Butter Cup

ADD TO BOX
photo
Rich chocolate cupcake with Sibby's rich and fudgy chocolate frosting
Our gluten-free cupcakes are made with gluten-free ingredients

Gluten-Free Choco Choco

ADD TO BOX
photo
Rich chocolate cupcake topped with vanilla cream cheese frosting and shredded coconut
Our gluten-free cupcakes are made with gluten-free ingredients

Gluten-Free Chocolate
Coconut Cream

ADD TO BOX
photo
Rich chocolate cupcake with vanilla cream cheese frosting
Our gluten-free cupcakes are made with gluten-free ingredients

Gluten-Free Chocolate & Cream

ADD TO BOX
photo
Vanilla cupcake with gooey caramel filling, topped with dulce de leche frosting
Our gluten-free cupcakes are made with gluten-free ingredients

Gluten-Free Dulce de Leche

ADD TO BOX
photo
Vanilla cupcake with espresso-infused coffee buttercream frosting
Our gluten-free cupcakes are made with gluten-free ingredients

Gluten-Free Latte Love

ADD TO BOX
photo
Rich chocolate cupcake with espresso-infused coffee buttercream frosting
Our gluten-free cupcakes are made with gluten-free ingredients

Gluten-Free Mmm Good Mocha

ADD TO BOX
photo
Vanilla cupcake with Sibby's rich and fudgy chocolate frosting
Our gluten-free cupcakes are made with gluten-free ingredients

Gluten-Free Old-Fashioned
Birthday Cake

ADD TO BOX
photo
 We are a nut-free bakery.

MENU

ORDER

WEDDINGS

ABOUT

CONTACT

DECORATIONS

SIGNATURE DESIGNS

CLASSIC THEMES

CUSTOM THEMES

RESOURCES

QUESTIONS

JOBS

PHILANTHROPY & DONATIONS

COVID-19 UPDATES

716 South Railroad Ave.
San Mateo, CA 94401
Call us at 415 613 4373
cupcakes@sibbyscupcakery.com

2024© Sibby’s Cupcakery. All rights reserved. Privacy Policy.